Committee on Energy and Commerce, Democrats Home Page
Who We Are Schedule What's New
View Printable Version

BUDGET FY2004

PRESIDENT BUSH'S MEDICAID
BLOCK GRANT PROPOSAL

What kind of damage will this proposal cause?

MEDICAID DAMAGE REPORT: THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET

Report prepared by
Committee on Energy and Commerce Democratic Staff

Many concerns have been raised:

"We are writing to express our opposition to any Medicaid reform proposal that seeks to impose a cap on federal Medicaid spending in any form or eliminates the fundamental guarantee to Medicaid coverage for our nation's most vulnerable citizens, including low-income children, parents, pregnant women, people with disabilities, and senior citizens."
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
48 Democratic Senators, 6/10/03 Letter to President Bush in opposition to Medicaid block grants (pdf)

"Working together, I am confident we can develop a bipartisan state fiscal relief package and a host of other reforms, including a structurally sound and meaningful Medicare prescription drug benefit."
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Senator Tom Daschle, 2/21/2003 Letter to President Bush (pdf)

"The undersigned organizations urge you, as members of the National Governors Association Medicaid Reform Task Force, to protect and strengthen the Medicaid program when considering reform proposals."
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)May 12, 2003, letter
to the NGA Medicaid Reform Task Force from many organizations

"National Health Associations Praise House Energy and Commerce Committee for Beginning Medicaid Reform Debate"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
American Health Care Association, March 12, 2003 News Release (pdf)

"Medicaid Reform Issues for Governors to Consider"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities 2/20/2003 Fact Sheet;
2/25/03 Report "The Medicare-Medicaid Link..."; and 2/12/03 report "The Bush Administration's Medicaid Proposal Would Shift Risks and Costs to States" (pdf)

"White House Wages Budget War Against Poor Children"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Children's Defense Fund, 2/3/03 Press Release and report "Radical Administration Medicaid Proposal Threatens Nearly 40 Years of Health Care Progress For Low-income Children" (pdf)

"Bush Administration's Medicaid Proposal Decimates Services for People with Disabilities"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Consortium for Citizens with Disabilities, 3/12/2003 Letter (pdf)

"...Recent cuts in the Florida Medicaid program give a painful preview of the human suffering which will ensue if the program is restructured to give states even more flexibility to reduce income eligibility standards and cap enrollment."
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Florida Health Groups, 2/4/03, Letter (pdf)

"Bush Medicaid Plan Spells Bad News For People Living With HIV/AIDS"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Gay Men's Health Crisis, 2/4/2003 News Release (pdf)

"Medicaid Matters to People with AIDS"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Several AIDS action groups, 3/7/03 Letter to State Governors (pdf)

"The Bush Administration's Medicaid and State Children's Health Insurance Program Proposal, by Cindy Mann"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Georgetown University Institute for Health Care Research and Policy, 2/10/2003 Report (pdf)

"Leading Aging Organization Says Proposed Budget Falls Short"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Leadership Council of Aging Organizations 2/13/03 Release

"Health care costs for metropolitan counties rise dramatically: Survey shows increases of over $5 million for some counties"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
National Association of Counties, 2/5/2003 News Release and report "Revisiting Uncompensated Health Care Expenses A Report" (pdf)

"Seniors, Disabled Face Loss of Services As Medicaid Budgets Cut; Financial Aid to States Needed to Keep Medicaid Safety Net Strong"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, 2/6/2003 Press Release (see also 2/6/2003 Letter to Congressman John D. Dingell) (pdf)

"The Administration's Proposal For Medicaid:  Block Grants Revisited"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
National Health Law Program Analysis (pdf)

"With so many citizens depending on Medicaid for critical health services, Congress must take quick action to shore up the program and protect our most vulnerable populations' access to care."
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
Premier, 2/5/2003 Letter (pdf)

"States need immediate help to ensure that their Medicaid residents receive appropriate health services"
bl_arrow.gif (136 bytes)
America's Hospitals and Health Systems, 2/25/03 Letter to Congress (pdf)

Many more concerns were raised, click here to see a list of those organizations.

Additional Resources on Medicaid:

 

Prepared by the Committee on Energy and Commerce
2125 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington, DC 20515