Press Release

Committee Leaders Request Nonpartisan Government Watchdog Examine EPA’s “Sue and Settle” Practices


Concerns with Transparency and Impact of Litigation on Proposed Rules

WASHINGTON, DC – House Energy and Commerce Committee leaders yesterday wrote to the Government Accountability Office (GAO) requesting an examination of the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) settlement of lawsuits that seek to compel the agency to undertake new rulemakings, also known as “sue and settle.” Members have particular concerns about the transparency of the settlement process, the public’s ability to comment and participate, and the impact on agency rulemakings that result from this type of litigation.

“EPA regularly faces litigation relating to implementation or enforcement of statutes or of its regulations, rulemaking activities, and other actions. Several environmental statutes have provisions that allow citizens – including individuals, states, non-governmental organizations, industry, associations and other entities – to file a lawsuit against EPA challenging certain agency actions or inaction, including lawsuits relating to potential new regulations,” wrote Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Fred Upton (R-MI), Energy and Power Subcommittee Chairman Ed Whitfield (R-KY), and Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee Chairman Tim Murphy (R-PA).

“In many instances, EPA has entered into settlements or consent decrees committing the agency to undertake significant new rulemakings subject to specific timelines or schedules, including rulemakings that may result in substantial new compliance costs. Concerns have been raised about the transparency of EPA’s negotiations and entry into such settlements, about the agency’s development of timelines and schedules, and about the ability of affected stakeholders or the public to participate meaningfully in the process before the settlements are finalized, as well as about the impacts of these citizen-suit settlements on agency regulatory processes and priorities.”

At the Energy and Power Subcommittee’s May 16, 2013 hearing on the EPA’s budget and priorities for Fiscal Year 2014, EPA Acting Administrator Bob Perciasepe discussed “sue and settle” concerns related to EPA’s rulemaking settlements and what the agency is doing to improve transparency of the process and provide more information to the public and stakeholders. Perciasepe committed to posting petitions for rulemakings on the agency’s website, something committee members have previously requested.

Read the letter to GAO here.


Press Release